Watchlist 2010
The Watchlist is a list of safety issues investigated by the TSB that pose the greatest risk to Canadians.
In each case, actions taken to date have been inadequate and concrete steps must be taken on the part of industry and the regulator to eliminate these risks.
Multi-modal issues
Implemented properly, safety management systems (SMS) allow transportation companies to identify hazards, manage risks, and develop and follow effective safety processes. However, TC does not always provide effective oversight of transportation companies transitioning to SMS, while some companies are not even required to have one.
- Marine: TC should require domestic commercial shipping operations to adopt SMS.
- Rail: Through audits and inspections, TC must proactively monitor SMS practices to ensure they are effectively applied by railways.
- Air: The integration of SMS practices into day-to-day operations must be closely monitored by TC to ensure that industry, as a whole, makes a smooth transition to an SMS environment.
Data critical to understanding how and why transportation accidents happen are frequently lost, damaged or not required to be collected.
- Marine: Operators of large domestic passenger ferries in Canada should be required by TC to install voyage data recorders consistent with international standards and practices.
- Rail: Industry needs to expand adoption of recently improved recorder standards to prevent the loss of data following collisions and derailments.
- Air: Global efforts are required to build better recorders, to enhance the quality and duration of their recordings, and to ensure they keep recording when the power supply fails.
Aviation issues
There is ongoing risk that aircraft may collide with vehicles or other aircraft on the ground at Canadian airports.
- Improved procedures and the adoption of enhanced collision warning systems are required at Canada's airports.
Fatalities continue to occur when planes collide with land and water while under crew control.
- Wider use of technology is needed to help pilots assess their proximity to terrain.
Landing accidents and runway overruns continue to occur at Canadian airports.
- In bad weather, pilots need to receive timely information about runway surface conditions.
- Airports need to lengthen the safety areas at the end of runways or install other engineered systems and structures to safely stop planes that overrun.
Marine issues
The number of accidents involving loss of life on fishing vessels remains too high.
- Industry needs to adopt and promote safe operating procedures and practices to increase safety knowledge of fishing vessel operators.
- Government should work with industry to improve training and awareness and provide a stronger regulatory framework to support these initiatives.
Emergency preparedness on large passenger ferries operating in Canada needs improvement.
- Large ferry operators must adopt and practice effective emergency preparedness procedures. This includes maintaining detailed passengers lists and practicing evacuations.
Rail issues
The risk of passenger trains colliding with vehicles remains too high in busy rail corridors.
- Transport Canada (TC) and the railways must conduct safety assessments to identify high-risk crossings along busy passenger train routes and make the necessary safety improvements.
Inappropriate handling and marshalling can compromise the safe operation of longer, heavier trains.
- Railways need to take further steps to ensure the appropriate handling and marshalling of longer, heavier trains. Detailed risk assessments are required whenever operating practices change.
Watchlist brochure
A brochure that summarizes Watchlist safety issues is also available: